Posts Tagged New York Times Book Review

NY Times Book Review: Why Criticism Matters

I am gonna miss the New York Times goes the behind a paywall, but until then I will link to it when they garner my attention. This week the New York Times Book Review considers the very nature of criticism in a brief editorial.

“We live in the age of opinion­ — offered instantly, effusively and in increasingly strident tones. Much of it goes by the name of criticism, and in the most superficial sense this is accurate. We do not lack for contentious assertion — of ‘love it’ or ‘hate it’, of ‘wet kisses’ and ‘takedowns’, of flattery versus snark, and assorted other verbal equivalents of the thumb held up or pointed down. This ‘conversation’ is often lively. Sometimes it is fun. Occasionally it is informed by genuine understanding as opposed to ideological presumption.”

,

No Comments

Podcast: New York Times Book Review

Book Review Podcast

Book Review Podcast

What could be better than reading the New York Times Book Review? Or Paper Cuts, the NY Times book blog? Listening to the Book Review podcast, of course.

For the week of October 23, the show covers “Jonathan Lethem, author of Chronic City; Frank Bruni on a new biography of Elizabeth Taylor; Motoko Rich with notes from the field; and Gregory Cowles with best-seller news. [Book Review Editor] Sam Tanenhaus is the host.”

The show started back to April 2006. I may try to point out some gems from the archives in the coming weeks and months. Be sure to share your own discovered gems from here, there or anywhere–in the comments section.

, , , ,

No Comments

John Williams on The Second Pass

second-pass

The Second Pass

I love books and I greatly admire people that write effectively about one’s love of good books.  The Second Pass (“an exclusively online publication devoted to reviews, essays, and blog posts about books new and old“) is the kind of concept I wish I had developed and that is overflowing with people that write effectively about books. After visiting the publication for awhile, I contacted the site’s founder and editor, John Williams, to garner a better understanding of what he’s trying to achieve. The site just celebrated its sixth month of existence and Williams entertained a series of questions from me. Williams’ career path to The Second Pass includes the following details: “From 2001-2007, he worked in the editorial department at HarperCollins. Before that, he spent time as a journalist in Texas and an editorial intern at Harper’s Magazine. His work as a freelance writer has appeared in Slate, McSweeney’s, Stop Smiling, the Austin American-Statesman, the Dallas Morning News, the New York Sun, and other publications.” My thanks to Williams for his time and for shepherding a site worthy of my jealousy.

Tim O’Shea: With six months of the site under your belt, what do you consider to be some of the successes and missteps of the site to date?

John Williams: I feel like the site overall has been a success. I’m proudest of the way people have responded to it, both general readers and people in the publishing business. The vast majority of the feedback I’ve received has been positive. I guess the most specific success was the “Fired from the Canon” feature, which hit a nerve with people and spread far and wide.

The missteps have been mercifully small (in terms of how public they are). For instance, I started the site with confidence that I could get material rolling in as I went, and that was a mistake. I should have had more “inventory” at the start. I feel like I’ve been playing catch-up in order to keep the site refreshed on a regular basis, though that’s finally starting to change. I guess another misstep would be my desire to have a “Letters” page, as a way of nodding to the tradition of letters to the editor. That’s been a bust, and I put a comments function up on the blog instead. I’m still trying to figure out what to replace “Letters” with, so the heading remains up on the nav bar for now — useless, like an appendix.

Read the rest of this entry »

, , , , , , , , , ,

1 Comment